REST (Representational State Transfer) is a simple, stateless architectural style typically running over HTTP which is common among web service implementations. REST depends on the use of standard methods such as GET, POST, PUT and DELETE. Until recently, there wasn’t an accepted standard for how REST services were defined. There was no service specification that Rational Integration Tester could synchronized to as an external resource. Web Application Description Language (WADL) is a specification recently ratified by the W3C for defining REST services. WADL models the resources provided by a service and the relationships between them. We will look at WADL in a bit, but it is important to understand how to define Rational Integration Tester REST schemas manually for a few reasons. First of all, you really need to understand what’s happening under the hood to understand how RIT uses the schema later. Secondly, WADL is new enough that many existing REST services do not have WADL specifications. And finally, there are some limitations in Rational Integration Tester’s support for WADL that may mean you need to manually adjust your model after synchronizing.
Creating REST schemas manually
The Login example
Forget about WADL for a moment. Let’s look at what a simple REST implementation might look like as an example. Let’s say the fictitious JKE Bank has a REST system that authenticates users of its online system. The REST URI for authentication looks like this:
Yes, I realize passing the password as a query parameter is highly unsecure, but play along with me, please. It illustrates my point well. Julie Brown is an account holder at JKE and she uses her pet cat’s name, Snuggles, as her password. The request to authenticate the user jbrown might look like this:
If you simply record a request message to this URL with Rational Integration Tester, how should the elements of the URL be interpreted? What constitutes the “operation” of this system? If you want to create tests for different users, you will want to create data-driven tests and stubs. How can you get RIT to substitute values from a test data file for the “jbrown” element of the URL? The answer lies in a REST schema definition in the Schema view of the Architecture School. REST schemas enable you to define which elements of the URL should be parametrized and which ones should be considered fixed values. To make the process of defining the schema easier, RIT provides the ability to import a URL template.
Once again, let’s use the JKE example to illustrate. Let’s say you have defined an HTTP connection in the logical view and associated it to a physical resource representing your web server. You record the request and you see something like this:
Recorded events for login of user jbrown
If you select those two events and attempt to save them as unit test with a simple data set, you will see where the problem comes in.
First Attempt at a Data Driven Test
You would want the username to be a column in your data file, but only the password has been identified as a parameter. So if you go ahead with this test as it is, this test can only be used for this one username – jbrown. Furthermore, notice that the operation has been identified as jbrown. In REST terms, jbrown is the unique ID for the resource. The operation should really be “user” – the element of the URI just before the unique ID.
This illustrates why Rational Integration Tester needs a little coaching in order to properly identify the fixed versus parameterized elements of the URI. That coaching comes in the form of a REST schema which is created in the Schema Library view of the Architecture School perspective. The simplest way that I have found to do this is to follow the steps below.
Enhancing the REST schema
Switch to the Schema Library view of the Architecture School perspective and select the REST schema type on the left. Here you see that RIT did create a schema when you attempted to create a test from the recorded events, but it needs some human intelligence applied to really make it useful.
Initial REST Schema for JKE User
First of all, the schema name is extracted from the hostname of the physical resource that was recorded. That’s not entirely useful, so we will change that to “JKE Services”.
Next, let’s edit the template for the URL by selecting it and clicking the edit icon.
Initial template for the JKE User URL
On the left side, you see the URL path segments. On the right, you see any query segments. The password part is pretty easy – it’s a pretty fair bet that anything that appears as a query parameter value is something you will want to parameterize. That’s why you see the curly braces around the password value.
But since RIT has only seen one URL, it has to make some guesses on what the URL represents. But the best guess RIT can make is that all elements of the URL are fixed. You can edit the schema a bit to make jbrown a parameter rather than a fixed element. You can also rename that parameter to something more descriptive of what it really represents, which is “username”.
The last thing you probably want to do is to change the template name from jbrown to something more appropriate like “user”.
Saving the test – Redux
With this schema in place, when you save the recorded events as a data-driven test, both the username and password are recognized as parameters and the operation name is identified as user.
Updated Data Driven Test
jbrown will be placed into the test data file as a parameter along with the password.
Test Data Preview
The retrieve accounts example
Next, let’s look at the REST request that retrieves Julie’s account information:
If you record the request and its response then attempt to save the events as a data-driven test, you will find again that the username element of the URL will not be identified as a parametrized value. I will use a slightly different procedure to create this template to demonstrate how you can import a URL template.
Creating the REST template for accounts
Copy the URL of the operation from the Header section of the Events View in Recording studio. In the Schema Library, use the Import URL Template tool and paste your URL into the dialog and click OK.
Initial Accounts Template
You can see here that RIT has done a rather curious thing. In the absence of a query parameter, RIT makes the assumption that every element of the URL must be a parameter. That’s not what you wanted either but again, you can edit the schema such that the username is the only parameter.
Updated Accounts Template
Now what about that WADL…
Now, all that is good to know, but I’m one who likes to avoid extra work if I can. So let’s get back to WADL…
As I mentioned earlier, WADL is relatively new and I have found that, although there is a W3C Specification for WADL, people interpret and apply the spec in various ways. Let’s take a look at ways we could represent the JKE interfaces in WADL.
Here’s how I think these services would be represented in WADL:
JKE Banking Fully Structured WADL
I mentioned some limitations in Rational Integration Tester’s WADL support at the beginning of this post. One of the limitations is that RIT doesn’t support parameters at the resource level yet – that’s something we expect in a future release. So I’ve reorganized the resource hierarchy a little in the following iteration of the WADL file:
Restructured JKE WADL
Now go to the Synchronization view of the Architecture School perspective in RIT and add a WADL reference to the external WADL file. This can be done with the Web > WADL toolbar action or the Add a new item to the view toolbar action. When you synchronize, you will see the following elements.
Let’s browse the model artifacts to see what was created by going to the Schema Library.
Schema Library for WADL
RIT left the schema untitled and uses a default name for the schema template of “url name”. This is something you should probably change to be more human friendly so name the schema JKE, the first template user and the second accounts.
Updated Schema Library for WADL
In the Logical View, the endpoint and two operations were created.
Synchronized elements in the Logical View
That first operation name looks odd. This is another limitation of the RIT support today. If the last element of the resource URL is a parameter, RIT doesn’t really know what to do about a name for the operation. You can rename the operation to something more appropriate like user.
Now open the user operation properties.
User operation properties
Several attributes such as the operation pattern and method were imported as well as the request schema.
One more limitation – My WADL had specified a mediaType of application/json but the schema for the Reply has been set as Text. This should be changed by browsing to JSON > Object.
Rational Integration Tester has some pretty powerful support for REST testing and virtualization. The nature of the beast of REST typically means you will need to do some coaching in the schema library to get RIT to understand the meaning of your application resources. RIT 8.5.1 has introduced support for WADL file synchronization. Although this support is evolving, there is a lot of value in using WADL to jump-start your model creation.